Comments

Log in with itch.io to leave a comment.

Viewing most recent comments 137 to 176 of 383 · Next page · Previous page · First page · Last page
(+1)

I am confused, in the beginning - Arthur mentions that he and Morgana come from the same womb... but that wouldn't be true. He is not a Le Fey, he is Uther's son but not the son of the woman his father SA'ed. If he were, they'd be full siblings and know about each other. Likely, Uther fathered Arthur with a commoner or an initial wife and then stormed in an assaulted the noblewoman he forced into marriage and had Morgana with her.

(1 edit) (+13)

No, Morgana is born to a previous father, Uther killed her father and takes her mother as his bride. Arthur is then born to Morgana's mother and is hidden away.

I think they meant that Morgana is a Le Fay due to her father, not her mother. Therefore Arthur cannot be a Le Fay

(+11)

Arthur and Morgana have the same mother - Igraine - and different fathers - Uther being Arthur's, Gorlois being Morgana's. It's Igraine who is the Le Fay, so the one whose bloodline carries magic; but just having magical blood doesn't ensure one actually has active powers and is thus a sorcerer. So Igraine, Morgana and Arthur are all Le Fay but only Morgana has the magical powers. 

Also, while Morgana is not Uther's bio kid, she was legally adopted by him - it's why she thought she had a claim to the throne.

(+1)

Again, awesome game. I don't really understand what "oblivious romance options" do. How are they different from regular romance options? Maybe there's a subtlety I'm missing since this is not my first language...

English is my first language and I don't know the difference ether.

(+15)

You the player know that Modred is getting romantic feelings for the character. Modred does not. Its letting you progress a romance without Modred realizing thats what they are doing, presumably culminating in a realization moment. 

(+12)

It's essentially you being shy/oblivious about your own feelings. It's a common thing in IFs like this to provide both a 'bold/direct' and 'shy/oblivious' option, which allows you to form a romance with a character in both ways. This helps for people who want to romance a character but don't want to be a flirt, and the player can still be 'pursuing' a particular character's route, but they are permitted to be shy about it, to be the 'pursued' instead, in some cases.

(2 edits) (+9)

Hit the nail on the head. I appreciate the options, as I usually don't like to play the obvious flirt. Or I can start with oblivious flirting at the start that progresses to bold flirting once the MC grows more confident in their growing relationship with the other character.

Or in this case, Mordred is still a young kid who hasn't yet hit puberty. Starting to like and be drawn to Galahad, but not yet aware that their feelings are the beginnings of a future romance.

(+3)

The way I understand it is that the options are meant for MC's who are dense enough not to notice themselves being a naturally-somewhat-subtle flirt.

I think its like when the mc doesn't realize or understand their own romantic feeling for an RO

(+8)

you are a saint for including a dark mode, bless you

(+1)

I love IFs and this one has made it into my list. Just wanted to show support as I'm normally a comment lurker.

(+10)

I don't tend to comment often, but with itch.io being the land of abandoned projects, i feel like i should show some support.

I really do hope you can finish this, i'd hate for it to be another cool game that suddenly stops being updated with the author disappearing completely. They're completely different genres and that one's more of a sandbox, but your game is up there with Trigaea if we're talking interactive fiction on this site, and imo that's the best finished one. You're doing an amazing job.

(+3)

WOW. I honestly forgot this was a demo?? so good and so polished, I really loved it, but can anyone tell me what choices I have to make to romance Galahad? 

(+9)

Thank you! ❤ Right now, besides Mordred crushing on Galahad there's not really more to his romance. And if you're interested about increasing your relationship with him in general - don't worry too much about it, the romance/friendship takes into account all sorts of routes, whether confrontational or friendly (basically I like it when you can challenge a character/disagree with them and it actually increases the relationship points). That said, there are certain choices in chapter 3 that can get him to start seeing Mordred in a different light. Generally the nice/soft/emotional ones, as well as things like telling him you're learning the magic of the Lady of the Lake and even one occasion where you kinda challenge his ideas. Anyway, going to the river with the intention of befriending him should help mellow him a bit!

(+8)

holy shit this is so good

(+6)

Yo a good story with dragons but like the dragon make sense in the society WHAT. (love this one)

(1 edit) (+6)

I'm simply awed by this story. It's been just way too long I have found a game I can actually sit through and read everything that's written there (way too many people think themselves way more interesting than they actually are). I love the complexity of the plot, how all the characters are flawed but also have their own reasons and motives, and oh how I love all of them (except Lot f- him). The relationships between all of them is just so beautiful and I love having the actual power of choice, changing things for real and not just some make believe to please. It's a marvelous work and I love every single thing about it. I'll be waiting excitedly for what the future awaits. Thank you dear author for all the care that has been put, it's quite visible how truly you care for this story - and how well you've made it! Okay, sorry for writing too much, I'll end it here with a big, strong recomendation for everyone to play this one; it is truly one of the worthy ones.

This is so much fun and I can't wait for more!!

(+5)

This my favorite game on Itch, no questions asked. My issue right now is when I try to launch the game, it takes me to the folder and I can't figure out how to actually play it. If anyone knows what the problem might be any help would be appriciated!

(+1)

This issue has me stumped right now so I too would really appreciate if anyone knew! It's really weird cause I've tried it on different devices and browsers and I can open the game fine. I've been trying to search the problem but I haven't found anything yet.

(-3)

I don't have that problem, when I launch the game it works fine.

(+1)(-1)

I adore this game! It's been so long since i've stumbled on one that I was so involved in both by the story and the characters ! I wonder though, is it planned to have more options to express anger/hurt toward Accolon in chapter 4 ? There's a few toward Morganna but oddly enough we can't express frustration or any kind of feeling toward Accolon when we can be mad at him for the prophecy

(+1)

I think its mostly because Mordred is still in shock towards the news, so they spend that moment trying to figure out 1) just how much Accolon knows, or condones and 2) is still trying to figure out how they feel about the event. In chapter 5 however, you're able to decide how you feel about him (though the options you get depend on what you choose your relationship with Morgana to be.) Though I do agree- I would like to have more options to express frustration or our feelings to Accolon after the reveal, though that's probably something best mentioned on the tumblr!  

(+2)

I think you're right, it just struck me as a tad bit odd considering you get to react almost immediately to the first reveal and can express it (may it be forgiveness or anger for a while toward both Accolon or Morganna) but have to wait a while (in game) to take any kind of decision for the second
Oh I rarely go to tumblr, I'll go take a look, thanks !

(+4)

I'll take a look over the conversation you can have with Accolon the next day after the reveal in chapter 4 for any possible reactions/choices to be added!

(+5)

This is really amazing, honestly. I love how you've taken the story of Mordred, allowed us the freedom to choose how Mordred is, and the incorporation of dragons into the very society of this world. I can't wait for more in the future. I especially want to continue my attempts to thaw Calahad's icy heart and make him Mordred's. xD

(+3)

I adore the writing of this game! ^^ I can't wait to see what's more to come.

I really enjoy the game, however with the latest update my game crashes to the file screen  when I try to open it.  Do you have any ideas for a fix?

In what sense do you mean? Are you unable to open the game at all, or does something happen while playing? Are you receiving any error messages?

I'm unable to open the game at all, no error messages. When I launch the game opens the file explorer window for the game data rather than the game itself.

Huh. I could open the game from different browsers, so it seems like an issue on your end. Do you have any add-ons that could be blocking the page?

Great so far.

(+4)

I wanna say, despite such long updates, I've still always waited for more. Which is somewhat surprising since that means there's something that keeps drawing me in. Maybe it's the fact that there's always a definite way to play Mordred how you want. Maybe it's the inevitable final chapter where chaos is gonna erupt.  Anyway, this is awesome and I love how we can play Mordred however we want. Definitely worth every wait

(+10)(-2)

My Mordred can no longer look at Morgana in the eyes after learning the true. Not matter her reason, some things simply cannot be forgiven. In his eye, she is worse than Merlin now. At least he isn't a rapist as far as he know. And she had the nerve call her victim a coward while she is the one who refuse to take responsibility for her action. And she tried to poisoned his image to her son, yet she call Merlin deceptive (don't get me wrong, he is, but she isn't an honest person herself).  What an hypocrite! The worse is how Arthur believe  he is somehow at fault despite being the victim.  Arthur never have time to heal and yet he still try despite Mordred being a reminder of his pain. Its ironic how Morgana is similar to Uther. The use of fear, the lust for power and of course, the rape. She  can't realize that Igraine would NEVER approve her actions. I wish my Mordred had the choice to tell her to her face that Igraine would be disgusted by her actions.

I just want to say that this is such a great game, I like the focus on the characters and their relationships. I also think it’s really well written especially how, unlike other games, it feels like Mordred and the others are experiencing actual character development that you can change over time unlike other games where it feels like you have to sick to a specific path because of stats. I can’t wait until Mordred finally meets Merlin and Guinevere, and meets Nimue again since I feel like she will be a very interesting character considering who her father is.

(+6)

Variables. So many variables. This game takes into account every possible reaction the MC might have to certain events, and it does its damned best to represent it in the game. It doesn't force you to rush against time, grinding stats and relationship points. Bastard of Camelot lets your MC grow with the story. The ones you hate may eventually become the ones most dear to you; the convictions you hold may gradually become a source of doubt. Trust can be broken and  hurting yet perserving love can remain. Humans are so rarely straightforward or linear when it comes to their emotions and actions, and BoC does its best to reflect that. Just thinking of all the coding that must have been put into these variations is making my head hurt, but!! I am very grateful!! The amount of character development and personality depth the game allows your MC to have is, quite frankly, insane. And I'm enjoying it very very much!

(+1)

This might already be known, but in my latest playthrough, I found a bug (I think) in Chapter 4, after finding out the truth and telling Arthur about it. After waking up in his room, I saw this:

"Arthur attempts to offer a sympathetic smile - the sentiment is touching but the result is more of a pained grimace, suggestive of his own anguish/suggestive of him feeling just as horrible as you."

I'm guessing the 'suggestive of X' lines are supposed to be one or the other, not both.

Yes, I must have missed it during editing! Thank you, I'll get it fixed as soon as I can!

(1 edit) (+1)

I just want to say... wow, this is great, some of the code could be better optimized, and there's a few grammatical errors, but you make up for that in sheer quantity AND quality of your writing, it has been a long time since I fell for an interactive fiction game, and this one has truly captured me. The entire story is amazing, but I've always loved ones of a darker nature as I found it easier to feel them. Anyways, I just wanted to say that this is amazing and I adore your writing, thank you.

(+2)

i listen to a playlist for this and whenever Galahad appears the song Ga1ahad and Scientific Witchery by Mili starts playing

(+11)

Galahad fr just dipped for a chapter or two. 

Does anyone else listen to music when they play this game? 

I personally listen to either: In my room instrumental sped up/looped or song of storms by the super guitar bros :)

(+1)

OMG I LOVEEEE THIS…I wasn’t expecting to be soooo infested as this was just in my recommendations but I ending up falling in love with the story!!

(+4)

I'm barking shaking rattling my cage, I need to now what happens neowwww!! (no pressure ofc) It's my mandatory llamagirl appreciation comment for giving us tboc. 

(1 edit) (+2)

I have played this like at least 20 times and stil not tired of it. Very good game

I have been on itch fot 2 years and this is the best game i have ever played

(+16)

Its been 2 chapters without Galahad WHERE IS POOKIE AT😭

(+7)

REAL!! I know my favorites be questionable sometimes but his name is literally Galahad so clearly he's the most forgivable asshole in this game 🙏🏽

(+5)

exactly omg like he could literally do anything and I would forgive him

(1 edit) (+3)(-2)

SOMEBODY WHO UNDERSTANDS ME!!!


 The confrontation and dragon scenes won me over immediately, I love the judgmental and inconsiderate moments (because 1. Who doesn't like a diverse set of characters with conflicting beliefs and principles??? And 2. It's legit always the most fun route with the best character development, I don't make the rules 🤷🏽‍♂️) AND It's so fun playing as an optimistic, sensitive, or just overly forgiving MC who shocks him. Or makes him question everything he thought he knew. 

Also fellow our life, dead weight, and a word without you fan??!!!! Edit: PROJECT HADEA AND OBSCURA TOO??? 

(+1)

Yess I love how shocked he is when the mc is nice and forgiving!! and I literally love those other games I  check for updates like EVERY  day

(+2)

Me but I follow every other social the developer has and check those too 🙏🏽

(+9)

i thought i was alone in my galahad obsession im so glad!!!!

(+8)

GALAHAD LOVERS UNITE!!!

(+3)

Gally simps unite!

(1 edit) (+4)

Pookie is showing up halfway through chapter 5 with the rest of the Camelot crew . Dw dw, we're seeing pookie again soon. 

(+2)

finally istg he js randomly disappeared 

(+4)

Lance went to go Propagandize him with Merlin's visions, dw dw he'll appear. Our communal husband was NOT lost at the supermarket. 

Wasn't that random there was no reason for him to show up again yet seeing as he's not Mordreds friend and I'm sure Lancelot wasn't gonna schedule a play date xD

(+1)

he should've come to our birthday party I mean like wheres my birthday kiss and stuff 

(+3)

Lancelot probably made him attend his why Mordred is evil classes

Your comment made me cackle so hard bro 

(+1)

FR im missing the beloved

(+1)

This is nice.

(+2)

If you talk with Nimue as a friend on the beach she only says Merlin doesn't trust Morgana either, but when you go to the dragon abode with Gawain at the feast and talk about Merlin, it still says "you wonder if she had given him the same warning", which at this point she hasn't done. Just a heads up!

(+1)

Thank you! I tweaked with the conversation with Nimue in chapter 1 and completely forgot it got referenced later :) Made the edit, will update the demo with it soon!

(+10)

Hey this is one of the best IFs I've played in here. This story got me feeling the whole spectrum of human emotions, all the characters are beautifully written and they feel so.. human. And just, the amount of choices here?! Like there's a lot?! There's way more than I used to play and its just. Amazing. Idk what else to put here but genuinely, thank you for the trans option. I'm trans myself and seeing it in game makes me cry like everyone be so supportive of trans mordred esp the part where accolon calls mordred his son eee thank you thank you.

(+1)

I love it so much made be cry a lot thou lol can't wait for more <3

(+5)

Wow I'm gonna read the beginning of chapter 5 for sure, this IF is so amazing. 😍

(+6)

Woooooooh! The teaser for chapter 5 is so cute! can't wait for more~ Thanks for all the hard work!

(+5)

I always loved enemies to lovers and with such amazing setting and writing it's trully breathtaking read.

(+7)

absolutely one of my favorite games in this site, genuinely. i love the characterization of every single one of the characters depicted here. arthur and morgana have got to be my favorites — a father that you know is a good person but has never done quite enough for you and a mother that does absolutely everything for you but you know isn't a completely good person? absolute perfection, and hits a bit too close to home honestly lol. and i also (especially) looooved the lore of dragons, every paragraph that includes those i ate it up.

amazing game, amazing writing. 

(morgana is such a My Mom — Eminem character).

Large delay in picking certain options on mobile

(+1)

You mean, delay between selecting a choice and the next page being loaded? I'm not having any issues with it and I haven't had other players report on it, so it doesn't sound like a game-specific problem.

(+2)

after playing through with a constant internet connection, here's a bit more detail:

the problem only occurs in choices about appearance (dragon, mordred, parents etc) and just had to be tapped a few times. I thought it was a save file issue at first but it'd persist even after reloading/restarting. 

Then I tested on my computer with the same wifi and didn't have any issues.

Truly have no idea if it's just my phone, but I still wanted you to know

Thank you for your time! 

(+11)

On a serious note: I think you've done incredibly well with this take on Arthurian myth -- and I am always a ho for Arthurian myth LOL. 


[WARNING: SPOILERS]

I love the theme of parents as people in this. Like, obviously Uther comes off as plain evil and Igraine as an angel, but considering they've both passed by this point, that's to be expected. The rest of the cast is wonderfully complex. In particular, the way you wrote the relationships between Morganna and Junia and Accolon got me. 

The easy thing to do would have been to write it so that neither Junia nor Accolon knew that Morganna had raped Arthur, and for them to abandon her upon learning of this. Most of the time in real life, it's a lot harder to abandon someone you love, even when you know they've done something horrible. Mordred and Gareth continue to love their mother because they're children and children tend to be fiercely loyal to their parents. Accolon and Junia do it because they know how good Morganna can be, if only she would step off this path she's taken. 

Junia standing up to Morganna was beautifully done. She saw her sister was falling apart and made the incredibly difficult move to stop coddling and enabling her bad decisions while still being sympathetic to the reasons behind them. Morganna has lost so much, and the only way to stop a full-on meltdown is to show her that there is yet more to lose if she continues. A wonderful example of "I love you enough to lose you."

And the way you've addressed trauma! Morganna and Arthur are absolutely adults who've made mistakes and need to correct them. But on another level, they are also still "stuck" as traumatized teenagers, visible in Arthur's timidness and Morganna's rage. Just a couple of scared kids. Lancelot appears to fall in here as well (I imagine he's been through some hell and that Morganna's attempt to drown him as kids hasn't helped). These three, contrasted with calm and mature Kay and Accolon, have a lot of pain to work through. You can see it in their parenting as well: Gareth, Galahad, and Mordred (if one chooses to play them as such) are all terribly mature and grave for children their age. Meanwhile, Gawain has far more childlike tendencies because Kay and Hilde Alistair didn't pass down trauma to him. 

Lot and Uther create your hard line of what a horrible person is, while characters like Kay fall firmly into "good," allowing everyone else to exist and move along the spectrum of "trying their best."

A final note: while I have been reading Morganna as a tragic villain (not sure if that was your intent?), I believe you have done her character justice. She is not insane, or evil for evil's sake, but rather someone who has stepped off a precipice and not reached the bottom yet. 

Beautiful work. 

(+3)

Thank you so much! ❤ And yeah, Morgana's intended to be a tragic villain 👀

(+3)

I'm glad I wasn't off with that interpretation then, LOL. 

I really do like your Morganna. More than I like Merlin (BBC)'s Morganna, and pretty neck-and-neck with the Morganna from Jean Townsend's Guenevere.

(+3)

cant wait for chapter 5 

Viewing most recent comments 137 to 176 of 383 · Next page · Previous page · First page · Last page